Captain D’s Sandwich Combos: Full Guide to Fish, Chicken, Flavor, and Portion Sizes
Sandwich Combos at Captain D’s offer crispy fish or chicken served on buns with sides and drinks. These meals are made for anyone who wants something filling but easy to eat; no forks, no big platters, just handheld seafood with fries and a cold drink.
I still remember the first time I tried the Giant Fish Sandwich. The fillets were falling off the edges of the bun, and I had to hold it with both hands. A guy at the next table bit into his and said, “Now that’s a sandwich,” and honestly, he wasn’t wrong. It’s big, crunchy, and comes out hot every single time.
This article covers everything you’d want to know before ordering one of these combos: what each sandwich includes, how they taste, how big they are, how many calories they pack, what they cost, which sides go best, and who usually orders what. Whether you’re here for lunch, dinner, or just hungry for something handheld, this will help you pick the right one. Let me know when you’re ready to start with the first section.
Giant Fish Sandwich
$7.59
Cal: 1010
Giant Fish Sandwich Combo
$10.99
Cal: 1010
Cajun Catfish Sandwich
$8.49
Cal: 840
Cajun Catfish Sandwich Combo
$11.99
Cal: 840
What Sandwich Combos Are on the Captain D’s Menu?
Captain D’s serves a small set of sandwich combos, but each one is built around its signature seafood. These combos come with a full sandwich, fries or another side, and a drink. They’re made for quick meals and solo orders. If you don’t want a full platter, these are your best pick.
What’s in The Captain Sandwich?
The Captain Sandwich uses a large fillet of batter-dipped white fish. It’s the same type found in their fish platters; crispy outside, soft inside.
The fillet usually covers the bun completely, hanging off the sides. Most people need both hands to hold it. It’s about 7–8 inches long, depending on how the kitchen cuts it.
Price sits around $6.49 to $7.29 depending on location, and that’s for just the sandwich. As a combo with fries and drink, it ranges from $9.49 to $10.29.
Flavor-wise, it’s mild and lightly salty. Tartar sauce adds tang, and there’s a layer of shredded lettuce under the fish to balance it. There’s no overpowering spice; this one works for all ages.
What’s in The Giant Fish Sandwich?
This combo is larger than The Captain. You get two full fillets of battered fish, stacked inside a toasted bun. Each fillet is about 6 inches, so expect overflow on all sides.
The bun is thick and soft, slightly sweet, and holds up well even if you take your time eating. With both fillets, the sandwich weighs over 11 ounces, making it one of the heavier handheld options at Captain D’s.
Crispiness is high; the batter holds its crunch until the last bite. Seasoning is the same as their classic fish: not spicy, not too salty.
It usually comes with fries and a drink in the combo. Most locations price it around $10.39, but it might go a bit higher in city areas.
What’s in the Cajun Catfish Sandwich?
The Cajun Catfish Sandwich uses two breaded southern-style catfish fillets. These are spicier and bolder than the classic white fish. The sandwich has a strong peppery flavor from the Cajun seasoning, and it leaves a little heat on your tongue.
This item isn’t always available nationwide. It’s most common in Southern regions, like Alabama, Mississippi, and Georgia, where catfish is more popular.
It comes as a combo or solo. The combo usually includes fries and a fountain drink. When I tried it in Jackson, MS, the combo cost around $11.99, while the sandwich alone was just under $8.
It’s a favorite for people who want something with kick but not overly hot.
What’s in the Fried Flounder Sandwich?
The Fried Flounder Sandwich is made with a single flounder fillet, usually oval-shaped and thinner than the white fish fillets. Flounder has a milder, sea-forward taste, slightly sweet, and the meat is softer than white fish.
The sandwich fits well inside a bun without too much overflow, making it easier to eat than the Giant Fish Sandwich. It’s commonly paired with tartar sauce, though some people ask for cocktail sauce for a sharper bite.
This sandwich shows up as a limited-time item in many regions but is often part of combo deals when available.
What’s the Texture and Bread Like?
Captain D’s sandwiches are built on soft, slightly toasted buns. From what I’ve seen and tasted, the bread has a light buttery surface but isn’t greasy. It holds shape even when paired with hot, crispy fillets.
Does the Bread Get Soggy with Sauces?
If you go heavy on tartar or cocktail sauce, the bun can get soft in the middle. But it doesn’t fall apart unless you leave it sitting too long. I always ask for sauce on the side when I know I won’t be eating right away. That helps keep the bread firm.
How Thick Is the Bread Compared to the Filling?
The bun is thinner than the fillet in most cases. This keeps the focus on the fish or chicken inside. You get more crunch from the protein than from the bread. The ratio works well; it’s not one of those sandwiches where you feel like you’re just chewing bread.
Is the Fish-to-Bun Ratio Balanced?
Yes, in my experience, the protein fills the bun end to end. There’s no empty edge bites like some other fast food places. The Giant Fish Sandwich especially stacks the fillets to the point where they spill out the sides. It actually feels like you’re getting your money’s worth.
Are Sandwich Combos Enough for a Full Meal?
If you’re hungry and looking for something that’s filling but not too heavy, these combos hit the mark. Each sandwich comes with one main side; usually fries or coleslaw; and a drink.
What’s the Portion Size for the Sandwich and Sides?
The sandwiches use full-size fillets, often 4 to 6 ounces depending on the type. The side portions are regular size, not downsized like in some kids’ meals. I’ve always left full without needing anything extra.
What’s Included in the Standard Combo?
A typical combo includes one sandwich, one side, and a medium drink. You can swap sides; fries, okra, mac & cheese, or coleslaw are the most common. Some locations also let you upgrade to a premium drink or large fries for a small charge.
How Does the Price Compare to Fullness?
Most sandwich combos range between $7 and $9. For what you get; protein, side, and drink; it’s fair. It’s more affordable than some of the larger platters and fills you up enough for lunch or a light dinner.
Are Sandwich Combos Better for Lunch or Dinner?
They’re perfect for lunch. If I’m in a rush or don’t want a plate meal, I go for the sandwich combo. For dinner, it depends; if you’re used to big dinners, you might want to add an extra side or dessert.
Flavor Profiles – Mild, Spicy, or Buttery?
Captain D’s sandwich combos offer a solid mix of flavor types; some are spicy and bold, while others stay mild and buttery. I’ve ordered all of them at least once, and the seasoning really does change the whole feel of the sandwich. If you’re someone who prefers lighter flavors or can’t handle spice, there are still safe and tasty picks.
Which Sandwiches Have a Spicy Coating?
The Spicy Giant Fish Sandwich is the boldest option. It uses a peppery batter that leaves a slight tingle on the tongue. It’s not over-the-top spicy, but for someone with a low spice tolerance, it could feel a bit strong. It’s best with a cold drink like lemonade to even things out.
What’s the Mildest Option for Sensitive Eaters?
The Giant Fish Sandwich (original) is mild, with no heat at all. It’s just classic batter and tartar sauce. The Fried Flounder Sandwich is also mild, and its softer texture makes it easy for people who don’t like crispy or spicy foods. Both of these are go-to picks for older customers or kids.
How Do Tartar and Cajun Seasoning Affect Flavor?
Tartar sauce adds tang and helps mellow out the saltiness. The Cajun Catfish Sandwich uses Cajun rub with a smoky, peppery base. It’s flavorful without being overpowering. Cajun lovers usually go for this one, especially when paired with coleslaw, which cools it down a little.
Which Sauces Match Best With Each Sandwich?
Tartar sauce works best with battered fish sandwiches. Cajun or spicy sandwiches do better with ranch or even plain ketchup if you want to tone them down. I’ve seen people dip the catfish sandwich in cocktail sauce too; it adds a bit of sweetness to the spice.
What Sides Work Best With Sandwich Combos?
Sides can either balance or overpower the sandwich. I’ve had combos where the fries made everything feel too greasy, and others where coleslaw made the whole meal refreshing. It really depends on what you’re pairing it with.
Which Sides Balance Out the Sandwich Flavor Best?
Coleslaw is a great match for any sandwich; it adds crunch, lightness, and a bit of sweetness. Green beans also work well if you want a warm side without grease. Broccoli is the healthiest and keeps the meal light, especially if you’re already having a breaded sandwich.
Which Combos Might Feel Too Greasy Together?
Fish sandwich + fries + hush puppies is the kind of combo that feels heavy. It’s filling, but if you’re not super hungry, you’ll probably need a nap after. I usually skip the fried sides when I go for the Spicy Fish Sandwich because the sandwich itself is already rich.
How Do Breadsticks or Corn Change the Meal?
Corn on the cob gives you something sweet and starchy without being oily. Breadsticks are soft and buttery, but they double up on carbs with the sandwich bun. I only take the breadstick when I’m skipping the fries; it’s too much otherwise.
What Are Customers Saying About Their Side Choices?
From what I’ve overheard while waiting in line or sitting down, most people ask for fries by default. But regulars often swap in coleslaw or green beans when they want a lighter combo. One guy at the table next to mine even asked if he could get double broccoli instead of fries and a drink.
Calories and Nutrition Facts
Sandwich combos at Captain D’s may look simple, but they can pack a good amount of calories depending on what you order and what you add on the side. I’ve checked the nutritional breakdown a few times before ordering, especially when I wanted something filling but not over the top.
What Are the Calories per Sandwich With and Without Sides?
The Giant Fish Sandwich alone comes in around 1010 calories, mostly from the double fish fillets and the buttered bun. If you go with fries and a drink, that adds about 400 to 500 more calories, depending on your drink size. On the other hand, the Fried Flounder Sandwich is lighter; closer to 780 calories by itself.
How Much Protein Is in Each Sandwich?
The Giant Fish Sandwich gives about 25 to 30 grams of protein, which is decent for a fast food meal. If you add chicken or catfish in other combos, the protein can go up slightly. These are full-sized sandwiches, not snack sliders; so they keep you full.
What About Fat and Sodium?
The fried coating and sauces bring in the fat. Expect around 60 to 70 grams of fat in a full combo meal with fries. Sodium is high too; often over 1000 mg per meal, especially if you go heavy on sauces or sides like mac & cheese. If you’re watching salt, you’ll want to skip the tartar and fried extras.
Which Combo Is Best for Calorie-Conscious Diners?
Your best option is the Fried Flounder Sandwich with broccoli and water. That combo stays under 850 calories total and still gives you protein and flavor without heavy sides or sweet drinks.
Who Usually Orders Sandwich Combos?
Every time I sit down at a Captain D’s, I notice a certain type of customer going for the sandwich section. It’s not the big family crowd or the people ordering giant platters; it’s usually folks who want a fast, neat, and filling meal without all the extras.
Are Sandwich Combos Popular Among Teens and Solo Diners?
Yes, especially teenagers and college kids. They grab sandwich combos more than anything else, probably because it’s cheaper than a platter and easier to eat with one hand while scrolling on their phones.
Do First-Time Visitors Prefer Sandwich Combos?
A lot of first-timers start with a sandwich combo. It’s a safe bet. You don’t have to figure out sauces or seafood types; you just get a bun, protein, fries, and a drink. I’ve recommended it to friends who’ve never been to Captain D’s before, and they always say it was an easy intro.
Are Sandwiches Common for Office Lunch Orders?
Yes. Sandwich combos are perfect for office folks. You don’t need a fork, there’s less mess, and it’s fast to eat between meetings. I’ve seen office groups ordering five or six combos at once; one for each coworker; with a mix of sides.
Do Families Add Sandwiches for Extra Kids?
Families usually go for the family meal trays but then add a sandwich combo or two for older kids or teens who want something of their own. It’s cheaper than ordering a second full platter and keeps the kids happy with something they can eat by themselves.
Best Sauce Pairings for Each Sandwich
Captain D’s sandwiches are flavorful on their own, but adding the right sauce can take them up a notch; or ruin the balance if you go overboard. I’ve tested a few combinations, and some definitely work better than others.
Is Tartar Sauce the Best Match for Fish Sandwiches?
Yes, tartar sauce is the go-to for all fish sandwiches. It adds tang and moisture without hiding the flavor of the fish. Especially with the Fried Flounder Sandwich, the tartar works like a glue that holds the bun and fish together in taste and texture.
When Should You Pick Ranch Instead?
Ranch pairs better with chicken. The creamy texture balances the saltiness of the breading and gives the chicken sandwich a bit of a cooling effect, especially if the chicken is seasoned or spicy. It doesn’t work well with fish, though; it can feel too heavy.
Are Cajun Mayo or Spicy Ketchup Available?
In some regions, Cajun mayo or spicy ketchup is offered for the Cajun Catfish Sandwich. Cajun mayo adds a smoky heat that blends well with the catfish’s natural boldness. Spicy ketchup is less common but can be asked for at select locations. It’s good if you want a punch of flavor without the creaminess of mayo.
Can Any Sauces Overpower the Fish Flavor?
Yes, definitely. Sauces like ranch or barbecue can mask the taste of mild fish completely. If you’re ordering a Giant Fish Sandwich, stick with tartar or plain ketchup. That way, the fried coating and fish still come through without being lost in sauce.
Are There Gluten-Free or Low-Fat Sandwich Options?
If you’re looking for a fully gluten-free or low-fat sandwich at Captain D’s, you’ll run into a few challenges. I’ve asked the staff before and checked the ingredients list. Everything in the sandwich combo section includes wheat.
Are All Sandwiches Breaded and Wheat-Based?
Yes, all sandwich fillets are breaded and served on wheat buns. That includes fish, chicken, and catfish sandwiches. There’s no gluten-free bun or unbreaded fish option by default. Even the sauces may contain small traces of gluten, depending on the batch.
Can You Order a Grilled Sandwich Instead?
Grilled fish sandwiches aren’t on the main menu, but some stores may let you build one if they have grilled fish ready. I once asked for grilled white fish on a bun with lemon pepper seasoning and they made it. It didn’t come with sauce by default, so I added a lemon wedge.
What Sides Can You Swap for Lower Fat?
If you’re avoiding fried food, ask to swap fries for broccoli or corn. Green beans are also a good low-fat side. Skip the breadstick and hush puppies to drop fat and carbs even more. A combo of grilled fish (if available), broccoli, and water brings the whole meal under 700 calories.
Sandwich Combo Deals and Promotions
Captain D’s sandwiches aren’t just about flavor; they also show up in some of the brand’s more budget-friendly deals. I’ve seen sandwich combos on promo boards during lunch hours more than once.
Are Sandwich Combos Part of Lunch Specials?
Yes, sandwich combos often show up in lunch specials, especially during weekday hours. You’ll usually find the Giant Fish Sandwich Combo or the Captain Sandwich listed with fries and a drink at a slight discount between 11 AM and 2 PM. Prices vary, but I’ve seen it go for under $7 during a lunch hour visit.
Are Sandwiches Ever Included in the $4.99 Deals?
Rarely. Most $4.99 deals include smaller plates like fish and shrimp with one side. However, in some limited-time offers, Captain D’s has added a basic fish sandwich + drink combo for that price. It’s not permanent, so it depends on location and season.
Can You Use Captain D’s Rewards on Sandwich Combos?
Yes. If you’re part of the Captain D’s Rewards program, you can redeem points for free drinks, sides, or desserts, even when ordering a sandwich combo. I’ve done it a few times; ordered a Giant Fish Sandwich and got a milkshake instead of soda, using just a few points.
What to Order First Time?
If you’re new to Captain D’s and scanning the menu for something safe but satisfying, the sandwich section gives you a few smart choices. I’ve recommended these combos to friends who didn’t want a full seafood platter but still wanted a solid meal.
What’s the Best Pick for Variety?
Start with the Giant Fish Sandwich Combo. You get two full-sized fish fillets, shredded lettuce, tartar sauce, a warm bun, fries, and a drink. It’s one of the most filling options without ordering a platter. You get both crunch and flavor in a handheld format.
Which Sandwich Combo Feels Lightest?
The Fried Flounder Sandwich with a side salad or broccoli is the better pick if you want a less greasy option. Flounder is softer and lighter than catfish or the thick-cut fish used in other sandwiches. Pair it with unsweet tea or water and keep it light all around.
When Should You Skip Sandwich Combos?
If you’re avoiding fried food, need gluten-free options, or don’t eat wheat, it’s better to look at grilled meals or salad-based plates. All sandwich combos include breaded proteins and wheat buns. There’s no fully gluten-free sandwich on the regular menu.
What Are Some Smart Ordering Tips?
Ask for sauce on the side so your sandwich doesn’t get soggy. If you’re cutting calories or watching fat, swap the fries for broccoli or green beans. You can also request no breadstick if you want to drop a few more carbs from your meal.