Captain D’s Desserts – Full Guide to Flavors, Calories, Prices, and Best Picks

What Dessert Options Are on the Captain D’s Menu?

Captain D’s offers a short but consistent selection of desserts. Each one is pre-portioned and served as a single-serving item, making them suitable for a quick end to a meal rather than a shareable course. I’ve seen most customers grab a dessert with combo meals or after a family order, especially when kids are involved. The dessert choices cover baked, fried, and chilled varieties.

Key Lime Pie

$4.99

Cal: 360

Classic Cheesecake

$4.49

Cal: 410

Funnel Cake Stix

$3.59

Cal: 320

What Are the Most Popular Desserts at Captain D’s?

The Funnel Cake Stix are usually the first to sell out. They’re warm, soft, lightly fried, and dusted with powdered sugar. Many people order them to share at the table or take home. Cheesecake slices (with or without strawberry topping) are also popular, especially with those who prefer a chilled dessert.

Are All Desserts Served Daily or Regionally Limited?

Based on what I’ve seen and ordered, all core dessert items; like Classic Cheesecake and Funnel Cake Stix; are usually available daily. However, Chocolate Cake or regional flavors might rotate or be temporarily removed based on location demand. It’s always better to check in-app or ask when ordering in-store.

Do Desserts Come in Individual Portions or Sharable Sizes?

All desserts at Captain D’s come in individual packaging. Funnel Cake Stix can be split between two people, but the portion is designed for one. Cheesecake and chocolate cake slices are standard-size, not oversized or share-plated. You won’t find any family-sized dessert trays on the menu.

How Do Captain D’s Desserts Taste and Feel?

Captain D’s desserts focus on simple textures and flavors that appeal to both kids and adults. None of the desserts feel too heavy, and most are easy to eat on the go or right after a fried meal. Based on what I’ve personally tried and seen others order, each dessert has a clear texture identity ; from soft and creamy to lightly crispy. There aren’t many surprises here, but that’s part of why they work.

What’s the Texture of the Cheesecake?

The Classic Cheesecake has a smooth and creamy feel with a slight firmness that holds its shape. It’s not overly sweet, and the base is soft without being soggy. The consistency stays the same whether it’s chilled for dine-in or picked up to go.

Are the Funnel Cake Stix Crispy or Soft?

Funnel Cake Stix are soft in the middle with a light crisp on the edges. They’re fried just enough to give that golden color but not hard or crunchy like fries. The powdered sugar on top sticks well and doesn’t fall apart when picked up. They taste best when warm.

Does the Chocolate Cake Feel Rich or Light?

The Chocolate Cake leans more toward light than dense. It’s moist, but not fudgy. The cake has a mild chocolate flavor that’s easy for kids to enjoy and doesn’t overpower the palate after a heavy meal.

Are Toppings Like Strawberry Sauce Sweet or Tangy?

The Strawberry Topping added to cheesecake is more on the sweet side with just a little tang. It’s thick enough to stay on the slice but not too syrupy. It tastes like preserved strawberries rather than fresh, which most customers seem fine with.

What Are the Ingredients and Allergen Warnings?

Captain D’s desserts use standard ingredients found in most quick-service desserts. While they taste homemade, they are prepared and delivered in bulk, meaning ingredients stay consistent across locations. Every dessert contains at least one major allergen, so if you’re ordering for someone with dietary needs, you’ll need to double-check before adding it to the tray.

Do Desserts Contain Nuts, Soy, or Wheat?

None of the current listed desserts at Captain D’s contain nuts as a main ingredient. However, they are prepared in environments where cross-contact with nuts or soy is possible. Most items, like cakes and funnel sticks, contain wheat. That makes them unsafe for anyone with wheat or gluten allergies.

Are Any Options Gluten-Free?

Currently, no dessert on the menu is certified gluten-free. All are made with standard flour or processed toppings that include wheat derivatives. Customers avoiding gluten would need to skip desserts or bring a personal treat if dining in.

Which Items Contain Dairy or Eggs?

Every dessert contains dairy and eggs. The cheesecake and cake slices both use milk and cream in their fillings and batters. Funnel Cake Stix are made from dough that includes eggs and milk. These are not suitable for dairy-intolerant or egg-allergic guests.

What’s the Average Price of Each Dessert?

Desserts at Captain D’s are priced to be affordable extras rather than premium items. From what I’ve paid and what I’ve seen on receipts, each dessert stays within the $2 to $4 range. Most people add them after building their meal, especially when ordering for a group or kids.

How Much Does a Slice of Cheesecake Cost?

A plain slice of cheesecake is usually priced around $2.99 to $3.29, depending on location. That price goes up slightly if you add a topping like strawberry sauce. It’s a single-serving size and is often boxed if not eaten in the store.

Is There a Price Difference for Toppings?

Yes, toppings like strawberry sauce may add an extra 30 to 50 cents. It’s a separate line item on some receipts, so if you’re on a tight budget, double-check before adding.

Are Desserts Included in Combo Deals or Add-Ons?

Desserts are not included in standard meal combos. However, you can usually add one for a small upcharge. Occasionally, they’re bundled into seasonal promotions, especially family meals or multi-person offers. They also count toward points if you use the Captain D’s Rewards app.

What Are the Calories and Nutrition Facts?

Captain D’s desserts offer a sweet finish to the meal, but they do come with added sugars and fats. Each dessert ranges from moderate to high in calories, depending on toppings and portion size. When I checked my receipt and compared nutrition info, I noticed most desserts are around the same calorie level as a side dish; sometimes even more.

Which Dessert Is Lowest in Calories?

The Funnel Cake Stix are one of the lower-calorie choices with about 320 calories per order. Despite being fried, their portion size is smaller compared to the cakes.

What’s the Sugar and Fat Content for Each Option?

Classic Cheesecake: Around 410 calories, 27g fat, and 36g sugar
Cheesecake with Strawberry Topping: About 460 calories, with 49g sugar
Chocolate Cake: About 300 calories, 11g fat, and 35g sugar
Funnel Cake Stix: 320 calories, 20g fat, 30g sugar

These numbers mean most desserts are not ideal for low-sugar diets.

Which Dessert Has the Most Protein?

The cheesecake wins here with around 6g of protein, thanks to the dairy content. Still, these aren’t protein-rich items; they’re treats, not supplements.

Can You Order Desserts Without a Full Meal?

Yes, I’ve done this a couple of times when I was craving something sweet after lunch elsewhere. You can walk in or use the app just to order a dessert.

Are Desserts Available as Standalone Orders?

All dessert items can be purchased without a meal. There’s no restriction or combo requirement, even for online orders.

Do Online Orders Include Dessert Customization?

Customizations are limited. You can usually add or skip toppings like strawberry sauce on cheesecake. But don’t expect a “build-your-own” type system. The options are fixed.

Can You Mix and Match More Than One Dessert?

Yes, but it depends on the store’s stock. I’ve ordered one cheesecake and one Funnel Cake Stix in a single order before. There’s no bundle discount, but the app and in-store menu let you add multiple items easily.

What Do Regular Customers Say About Captain D’s Desserts?

Feedback about desserts is mixed, mostly based on sweetness level and texture. During one visit, I overheard a group of older customers say the Funnel Cake Stix were too sweet for them, while a younger group loved them.

Are Any Desserts Considered Too Sweet or Too Small?

The cheesecake with topping is sometimes described as “sugar overload” in reviews. On the other hand, some say the slices feel a bit small for the price, especially if you’re expecting a restaurant-sized portion.

What’s the Favorite Among Returning Diners?

The Classic Cheesecake is usually the go-to. It’s balanced and familiar. Funnel Cake Stix are also popular for kids and teens because of their fun shape and powdered sugar.

Do Kids Enjoy These Desserts or Leave Them Half-Eaten?

In my experience, younger kids tend to leave the cheesecake half-eaten due to the dense texture. But they finish Funnel Cake Stix almost every time, especially when shared.

What Dessert Should You Try First?

If you’re trying Captain D’s desserts for the first time, start with the Classic Cheesecake or Funnel Cake Stix. Both are simple, sweet, and easy to eat after a meal. I’ve personally had the plain cheesecake several times, and it always feels like a safe, not-too-heavy finish; especially if you’re full but still craving something sweet.

Best Starter Pick: Plain Cheesecake or Funnel Cake Stix?

Go for the plain cheesecake if you want creamy and rich with no mess. Pick the Funnel Cake Stix if you’re more into warm, fried sweetness and don’t mind powdered sugar on your fingers. I’d recommend the Stix for kids or casual diners. The cheesecake works better for those who want a classic dessert.

Lightest Pick for After a Full Meal?

After eating a full combo with sides, the Funnel Cake Stix feel lighter since the portion is smaller and they’re easier to share. The cheesecake, although lower in carbs, feels heavier due to its thick dairy texture.

When to Skip Desserts (if you’re ordering family meals)?

Skip dessert if you’re already getting a Seafood Feast or 14pc Chicken Family Meal. Those meals are very filling and come with hush puppies and sides. You won’t have room unless you’re planning to save the dessert for later.

Tips for Best Taste: Eat in-store vs Takeout?

Eat desserts in-store if you can. Funnel Cake Stix lose their crispiness in the box after 10 minutes. Cheesecake is fine cold, but if it’s sitting in a hot car, it might get mushy. I’ve had the Stix delivered once, and they weren’t bad; but they didn’t hit the same way as fresh.