Captain’s Classics – Full Breakdown of Fish, Shrimp, and Chicken Combos

Captain’s Classics are combo meals at Captain D’s that include fish, shrimp, chicken, or a mix of all three. They’re designed for people who want more than one thing on their plate without paying for separate meals. Every time I’ve ordered one, it’s felt like the best value-for-variety option on the menu, especially when I can’t decide between shrimp or tenders.

These meals usually come with two sides and a breadstick, making them more filling than single-item meals. Some combos give you two proteins, others give you three. It’s a section of the menu I go back to often because I like switching it up, and this lets me try different textures and flavors in one plate.

In this article, I’ll walk through the full list of Captain’s Classics combos. I’ll explain what each one includes, how big the portions are, what they taste like, and what kind of side dishes match well with them. You’ll also get info on price ranges, calorie counts, and tips for choosing the best one based on your appetite and budget.

Deluxe Seafood Platter

$13.99

Cal: 1100

2 Piece Fish & 6 Piece Butterfly Shrimp Meal

$11.79

Cal: 820

2 Piece Fish & 2 Piece Chicken Meal

$12.59

Cal: 820

Supreme Sampler Meal

$14.59

Cal: 1180

15 Piece Butterfly Shrimp Meal

$10.49

Cal: 900

20 Piece Butterfly Shrimp Meal

$12.99

Cal: 900

What Are Captain’s Classics Meals Made Of?

Captain’s Classics meals at Captain D’s include three main proteins: Batter-Dipped Fish, Hand-Breaded Chicken Tenders, and Butterfly Shrimp. These are the most popular items on the menu, and this combo section is where they’re mixed and matched into full meals.

Which Proteins Are Included?

• Batter-Dipped Fish: Crispy on the outside, soft inside
  
• Chicken Tenders: Juicy, hand-breaded, not too spicy
  
• Butterfly Shrimp: Crunchy and seasoned, served with tails
  

You can expect at least two of these in every Captain’s Classics combo. Some meals even include all three, giving a bit of everything for those who can’t pick just one.

What Are the Combo Formats?

Most meals come in either 2-item or 3-item formats:

• 2-item combos might have fish and shrimp, or chicken and fish
  
• 3-item combos, like the Supreme Sampler, include fish, shrimp, and chicken in one plate
  

This gives customers the freedom to enjoy more than one flavor and texture without ordering a second entrée.

Why Are They Called “Classics”?

They’re called “classics” because they rarely leave the menu. These combos have been around for years and stay the same in most locations. People come back to them again and again, which is why they’ve earned the label.

How Many Sides Come With Each?

Every Captain’s Classics combo includes two sides and one breadstick. You get to choose your sides, so whether it’s fries and mac & cheese or coleslaw and green beans, you can build the plate how you want.

What’s Inside the Supreme Sampler?

The Supreme Sampler is one of the most loaded meals at Captain D’s. It includes:

• Two Batter-Dipped Fish fillets
  
• Two Chicken Tenders
  
• Six Butterfly Shrimp
  
• Two sides of your choice
  
• One breadstick
  

Who Is the Supreme Sampler Good For?

This combo works well for people with big appetites. I’ve ordered it when I skipped lunch and needed something heavy. But it also works as a shared snack between two people, especially if you add extra sides. It’s not officially marketed as a shareable meal, but I’ve split it a few times.

What Are the Best Sauces and Sides to Pair?

• Tartar sauce: Great with the fish
  
• Honey mustard: Pairs perfectly with the chicken tenders
  
• Cocktail sauce: Works best with shrimp
  

For sides, fries and mac & cheese make it a comfort meal. If you want something lighter, go with broccoli or green beans to balance the plate.

What’s the Calorie Count and Price?

The Supreme Sampler is around 1180 to 1250 calories, depending on your side choices. The protein alone adds up fast. Price usually falls between $8.99 to $10.49, depending on the region. For the amount of food you get, it’s a good deal, especially if you’re hungry or want to sample all the big hitters in one go.

What Makes the Deluxe Seafood Platter Different?

The Deluxe Seafood Platter at Captain D’s stands out because it’s one of the few combos that packs three types of seafood into one plate: stuffed crab shells, butterfly shrimp, and batter-dipped fish. No chicken, no extras; just a full seafood experience from start to finish.

What Items Come With the Deluxe Seafood Platter?

• Two Batter-Dipped Fish fillets
  
• Six Butterfly Shrimp
  
• Two Stuffed Crab Shells
  
• Two Sides of your choice
  
• One Breadstick
  

It’s built for those who want nothing but seafood, and it’s one of the richest combos in terms of both texture and taste.

Who Is This Meal Right For?

If you’re a fan of seafood variety, this is your go-to. The stuffed crab adds a unique texture; softer and more seasoned than the usual items. That part alone makes the meal feel fancier than other combos. But it’s not for everyone. Some people find it a bit heavy, especially when paired with fries or mac & cheese.

I’ve ordered this when I wanted something with more bold flavors, and it was filling enough that I didn’t need anything else for the rest of the day.

How Does Each Item Taste and Feel?

• Fish: Crispy outside, flaky inside
  
• Shrimp: Slightly firm, juicy with crunch
  
• Crab Shells: Soft, seasoned, with a crumbly top layer
  

This meal does feel heavier than others because of the crab stuffing. So if you want something lighter, you might want to skip this one or share it with someone.

Does It Contain Allergens?

Yes. This platter includes shellfish, fish, and wheat. The crab shells and breaded items all contain wheat, and the shrimp and crab will trigger shellfish allergies. Definitely avoid this meal if you have any of these sensitivities.

2 Pc Fish and Chicken – Best of Both Worlds?

This combo gives you two Batter-Dipped Fish fillets and two Hand-Breaded Chicken Tenders. It’s one of the more balanced meals because you get both land and sea in one plate. I usually order this when I can’t pick between fish or chicken, which, honestly, happens more than I’d like to admit.

When Should You Pick This Combo?

It’s ideal for anyone who enjoys both flavors but doesn’t want a full seafood meal. If you’re dining with kids or picky eaters, this combo works well. The mix of textures and protein types gives you more to enjoy in one plate.

What’s the Portion Size for Each?

Each fish fillet is around 3 oz, and each chicken tender is just under 2 oz. So you’re getting about 10 oz of protein total, not counting sides or the breadstick.

How Do The Textures Compare?

• Fish: Crispy on the outside, soft inside, mild flavor
  
• Chicken: Crunchier coating, firmer texture, seasoned but not spicy
  

Together, the mix keeps the plate from feeling repetitive. It’s a good choice if you like dipping one piece in tartar sauce and the next in honey mustard.

Does It Reheat Well?

Yes, but with some tips. I’ve reheated this meal once using an air fryer, and it held up well. The chicken stayed crispy, and the fish didn’t go soggy. If you’re using a microwave, the texture will be softer, but the flavor stays fine. Just skip reheating the breadstick unless you like it chewy.

Fish and Shrimp – A Lighter Combo Option?

The Fish and Shrimp combo at Captain D’s is a good pick for anyone who wants to skip chicken but still enjoy variety. It’s made with two Batter-Dipped Fish fillets and six Butterfly Shrimp, along with two sides and a breadstick. I usually go for this when I want something fried but not too heavy.

Who Should Choose This Combo?

If you’re not into chicken or just want a seafood-only plate, this one hits the mark. It gives two textures; crispy fillet and crunchy shrimp; without overloading your plate. It’s also more balanced in portion than the bigger samplers.

How Do the Fish and Shrimp Compare in Flavor?

• Fish: Has a thick, fluffy batter. It’s mild and holds tartar sauce well.
  
• Shrimp: Lighter breading, more peppery. It has a slight crunch and works well with cocktail sauce.
  

The two don’t taste the same, which keeps the combo interesting. You’re not getting “just more of the same” on your plate.

What Are the Best Sauces to Use?

• Tartar Sauce: Best with the fish
  
• Cocktail Sauce: Sharp contrast that lifts the shrimp flavor
  
• Ranch: Works with both, but makes the plate heavier
  

You can ask for two or even three sauces. I’ve done that a few times without extra charge.

How Many Calories Does It Have?

The full meal comes in at around 810–850 calories, depending on sides. You’ll get about 30g of protein, mostly from the fish. If you choose broccoli and green beans as sides, you’ll keep the total under 900 without losing flavor.

15 Pc Butterfly Shrimp – Who Orders This?

The 15 Piece Butterfly Shrimp meal is built for shrimp lovers. It includes 15 hand-breaded shrimp, two sides, and a breadstick. I’ve seen regulars go for this when they’re skipping fish entirely, especially those who want a quick, filling seafood bite without switching flavors.

Is It a Solo Meal or Shared?

This combo works both ways. It’s filling for one if you’re hungry, but also makes a solid shared snack between two people. I’ve ordered it for takeout before a movie night, and it was enough for me and one other person with a side of fries and coleslaw.

What Is the Shrimp Breading Like?

The breading is light, crunchy, and sticks well to the shrimp. It doesn’t feel oily, which is surprising for a fried item. Each piece is bite-sized but has a firm texture. It’s not rubbery or soggy, which keeps people coming back to it.

What’s the Nutrition Breakdown?

• Calories: Around 900 total with standard sides
  
• Protein: About 23–25g from the shrimp
  
• Best sauces: Cocktail sauce, ranch, or D’s Dippin’ Sauce
  

If you want to lighten the meal, you can skip one side or replace it with broccoli. But honestly, most people go all-in with this combo.

This meal is especially popular with diners who avoid fish due to taste or allergy. The shrimp brings seafood flavor without the stronger notes that some fish combos have.

Chicken-Only Classic Meals – Are They Worth It?

Not everyone heads to Captain D’s for seafood. Some stick to what they know; chicken. The Hand-Breaded Chicken Tenders meal includes four tenders, two sides, and a breadstick. It’s simple, familiar, and safe, especially for picky eaters or kids.

Why Do Some People Pick Chicken Over Fish?

From what I’ve seen, families often order this for younger kids who aren’t into seafood yet. I’ve also picked this combo on days when I wanted something mild or wasn’t in the mood for fried fish. Chicken tends to be the safe, middle-ground choice when sharing meals with others.

What’s the Texture and Oil Level Like?

The chicken tenders are firm, not dry, with a golden breading that’s slightly crunchy but not thick. They’re less oily than the battered fish but still fried, so you can expect a little grease on the plate. The meat inside stays juicy if you eat it fresh.

How Does It Compare Nutritionally?

• Calories: Around 730 with sides
  
• Fat: Slightly lower than the Deluxe Seafood Platter, but higher than grilled meals
  
• Protein: Around 35–40g depending on the size of tenders
  

If you’re aiming for less fat, skip the fries and pick coleslaw or broccoli as sides.

Portion Sizes Across Captain’s Classics

Knowing how much food you’re getting helps when choosing between meals. Here’s a quick breakdown of protein sizes before and after cooking for Captain’s Classics.

Protein Weight Comparison (Avg. Per Meal)

These are averages. Some locations may vary slightly based on local prep.

Sides Included With Combos

Every Captain’s Classics combo includes:

• 2 standard sides (fries, mac & cheese, coleslaw, green beans, etc.)
  
• 1 breadstick (unless you swap it out or skip)
  

So no matter what protein combo you go for, the meal ends up with a full plate.

Which Combo Feels More Filling?

If you want fullness for longer, combos with chicken and fish tend to be heavier. Shrimp-only plates feel lighter but crunchier. Meals with stuffed crab feel denser due to the filling.

From a price-to-satisfaction view, the Supreme Sampler gives the most variety, while the 2 Pc Fish and Chicken gives the most protein per dollar. If you’re feeding one hungry adult, either works. For smaller appetites, stick with the fish and shrimp mix or just chicken tenders.

Nutrition Breakdown by Combo

Understanding nutrition differences in Captain’s Classics helps pick a combo that fits your needs. Here’s a straight comparison of the most common meals based on typical portion sizes and sides.

Calorie, Fat, Protein, and Sodium Comparison

Numbers vary slightly based on side selections. This list assumes common sides like fries and hush puppies.

Which Classic Meal Is Lowest in Calories?

The 4 Pc Chicken Tenders meal is the lowest in calories among the full Captain’s Classics category. It stays under 750 calories even with sides like green beans or broccoli.

Which Combo Has the Best Protein-Per-Dollar Value?

The 2 Pc Fish & 2 Pc Chicken combo gives you high protein (nearly 40g) and costs under $9 in most regions. It balances meat quantity with taste variety, making it a great value choice.

Which Combo Is Best for Lighter Eaters?

If you want a smaller meal but don’t want to skip flavor, go for the 2 Pc Fish & 6 Shrimp. It’s filling, but doesn’t overload with fried items.

Which Is Best for Hearty Appetites?

The Supreme Sampler gives the most food and variety in one box. It’s ideal for anyone who skipped lunch or plans to share a bit. You get three proteins and sides, so the tray feels full without needing extras.

Best Sauces and Sides to Pair With Captain’s Classics

Building the right plate is more than just picking the main combo. Sauces and sides shape the entire experience. After years of ordering here, I’ve landed on some winning combinations; and some you might want to skip.

Best Sauce Matches by Protein

• Fish: Always works with tartar sauce. It adds a creamy contrast without overwhelming the flavor.
  
• Shrimp: Cocktail sauce brings a sharp, tangy bite. It’s refreshing, especially with fried shrimp.
  
• Chicken: Ranch is the go-to. Honey mustard also works if you like something a bit sweeter.
  

You can ask for extra sauces without a fuss. I usually ask for one of each and mix depending on the bite.

Best Side Pairings by Meal Type

• Fish-focused combos: Fries + coleslaw
  
• Chicken-based combos: Mac & cheese + green beans
  
• Shrimp-heavy combos: Corn + fries
  

These combos balance out the plate. Coleslaw helps cut through fried textures. Mac & cheese adds comfort. Green beans lighten the meal.

Which Combos Feel Too Heavy Together?

Ordering mac & cheese with fries and a fried seafood platter? Expect to feel full fast; sometimes too full. That’s fine if it’s your only meal of the day, but it might slow you down if you have plans later.

Tips for a Balanced Plate

Here’s what I’ve learned:

• Mix one fried side with one fresh or veggie side
  
• Don’t skip the breadstick unless you’re really cutting carbs
  
• Add lemon juice over fish to brighten the flavor
  
• Use sauces lightly; too much hides the actual taste

Are Captain’s Classics Good Value?

Captain’s Classics meals usually fall between $7 to $10, depending on what combo you pick and your location. For that price, you’re getting two proteins, two sides, and a breadstick. From my visits, they’ve always felt like the most complete plate without needing to add anything extra.

What’s the Protein Per Combo and Cost Per Gram?

Here’s a look at rough protein content and how it stacks against cost:

From a protein-per-dollar perspective, the Supreme Sampler wins hands down. It gives you the most food and still keeps the price under $9.

Which Combo Offers the Most Variety?

The Deluxe Seafood Platter and Supreme Sampler both give you fish, shrimp, and either chicken or crab. If variety is what you’re after, these two are your best bet.

But if you just want two types of meat without going overboard, 2 Pc Fish & 2 Chicken balances flavor, price, and size better.

Any Promotions or Discounts?

You can use the Captain D’s Rewards App to get deals on these combos. I’ve personally earned a free drink and side just by ordering the Classics a few times. They also run limited-time offers, like 2-for-$10 deals, that include some of these combos.

So yes, Captain’s Classics give solid value. If you’re new to Captain D’s and want a safe starting point, any of these meals will give you a little of everything without overspending.

Who Orders Captain’s Classics Most?

From what I’ve seen while sitting in Captain D’s during lunch rushes and early dinners, the Captain’s Classics are the default order for a wide mix of people. They’re not too big, not too small, and offer just enough to satisfy without needing to customize much.

What Kind of Customers Go for These Meals?

• Families often order multiple combos and share among kids and parents.
  
• Regulars who already know what they like stick to combos that include fish or shrimp.
  
• First-timers go for fish and chicken to play it safe.
  
• Teens and younger customers usually order shrimp-heavy or fish-only boxes; they skip chicken more often than older diners.
  
• Chicken-only meals are common among kids. Parents usually pick those when their children are picky eaters.
  

When Are Captain’s Classics Ordered Most?

The bigger combos like the Supreme Sampler or Deluxe Seafood Platter show up more during dinner hours. Lunchtime orders lean more toward fish and shrimp since they’re lighter and easier to finish during a break.

In short, Captain’s Classics are for people who want balance, variety, and value without complicating the order. It’s the most crowd-pleasing section on the menu for a reason.

What Should First-Time Customers Try?

If it’s your first time at Captain D’s, the Supreme Sampler is your safest bet for variety. You get a little bit of everything; Batter-Dipped Fish, Butterfly Shrimp, and Chicken Tenders; all in one box. It’s hard to go wrong with this mix because it covers the main items the restaurant is known for. That’s exactly what I ordered on my first visit, and it helped me figure out what I liked most without committing to just one thing.

What’s the Easiest Combo to Start With?

If you’re looking for something easier to finish and not too heavy, go for the Fish and Shrimp combo. It skips the chicken, so it’s lighter on oil and feels less filling. The textures are also more similar, which makes the flavor combo smoother; crispy fish, mild shrimp, and classic sides like coleslaw or fries.

When Should You Skip Captain’s Classics?

If you want only grilled items or you’re looking for a gluten-free option, the Captain’s Classics probably aren’t the best fit. Most of these combos are fried and include breaded proteins, which contain wheat. In that case, stick to the grilled meals or customize your plate with allergen-safe sides.

Smart Tips for Your First Order

• Swap fries for something lighter like broccoli or green beans
  
• Ask for sauce on the side so you can control how much you use
  
• Go at lunch hours if you want the best deals
  
• Use the rewards app; you might already earn a free drink or dessert on your first few orders